DrumsUp
Tiger Talk Pro
Reged: Dec 06 2005
Posts: 154
Loc: Cape Breton Nova Scotia Canada
|
|
I play in a lot of venues with very small stages, and there is often literally no way to set up where I can get away from the amps. Our guitar players tilt their amps so they are directed more at their ears, but our bass player's amp is aimed at the back of his knees. As you can guess, he cranks it up to where he is the only person I can hear. Not only does this destroy the musical experience for me, but my hearing is taking a hit as well. I'm currently using the Vater ear plugs with the 33db filter but I need more. I purchased a set of headphone style protectors that construction workers use, but they seem to ENHANCE the low end, making it worse. I am wondering who among you has had any experience with the Vic Firth version of these. http://www.long-mcquade.com/products/2445/Drums/Accessories/Vic_Firth/Isolation_Headphones.htm Do they reduce ALL frequencies, or do they too boost the low end? Any ideas/suggestions?
-------------------- "Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons, for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup."
|
bongobrad
Tiger Talk Trainee
Reged: Nov 30 2010
Posts: 22
Loc: WI
|
|
I can't help you with what to wear, but I will tell you this- PROTECT YOUR HEARING NO MATTER WHAT. You are on the right track. Do whatever it takes.
|
DrumsUp
Tiger Talk Pro
Reged: Dec 06 2005
Posts: 154
Loc: Cape Breton Nova Scotia Canada
|
|
Thanks bongobrad. I've been aware of the need for protection since the '90s, and it's been a constant search for the "perfect" protectors since then. I went ahead and bought the Vic Firth model which offer quite pleasant results.
-------------------- "Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons, for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup."
|
Bam
Tiger Talk Trainee
Reged: Aug 30 2011
Posts: 3
Loc: Charleston, SC
|
|
I'm VERY particular about my hearing. I actually can't stand loud noises ...music, that's different. Maybe I am very "old school" but Hearos seem to work just fine for me. It really depends on the venue I'm playing. Normally I'd say either Hearos or not depending on how it sounds on stage. If I'm playing behind a drum shield, I have to use the Hearos hands down. Depending on how it sounds on stage I might even use a combination of Hearos and an in-ear monitor. It all depends. I'm not concrete on what I feel is the best hearing protection so I'm willing to try just about anything.
-------------------- The Lazy Drummer
|
bear45
Tiger Talk Pro
Reged: Dec 27 2003
Posts: 159
Loc: CT
|
|
Look guys and girls - PROTECT YOUR EARS
the only reason i can hear well enough to get by today is that i gave all this up in the early 70s and didn't return to it for a long time
Hearos and similar are foam ear plugs they do not cut linearly as in simply turning the volume down they cut the highs much more than the lows (but better than nothing) thats why i didnt use foam earplugs back in the 60s. everything was muffled i have always been sensitive to loud noises and remember getting physically ill at times
like hearing cream live in a giant nightclub standing about 40 feet from them - that was a huge cinderblock room and nothing more - I HATE MARSHALL STACKS!!!! - and playing a loud gig also.
now, if you love doing this and playing music so much that you dont mind subjecting your self to what i experienced without some protection, think of it this way - you wont be able to do it when you get to my age or even younger- and because you love it so much think of how miserable you will be - been there done that
I am very lucky, but without certain sacrifice - 66 and I can still converse in a quiet area - but i do say 'what?' a lot - or cock my ear to my wife so she repeats the key words with any background noise its rough all my highs are gone and starting to cut into the consonant range.
now there are very practical alternates to protect your hearing. I cannot go into a bar that is any kind of noisy which means most of them when they get the music playing without my ears all frying up and cant hear afterwords for days to even a week or more. nerve damage
I cant tolerate noise levels that other people still can endure in some places you think you can tolerate the noise but you are doing damage to your ears it catches up in time. if there is a dj in there i have to plug up or leave
example hooters with its wood paneling i cant go in there without my hearing protection
look up ETYMOTIC MUSICIANS EAR PLUGS they make ones that are little rubber cones stacked up and come in different db cuts they cut the sound down linearly in other words the highs and lows are evenly attenuated you can get used to them and hear the music nicely I carry them with me all the time and when we go out to eat some places i have to insert them
you can online order and will cost you less than $20 do a search and see the competitors I cannot go out and go into most bars and some restaurants without this protection I am on the edge right now my highs are gone
when I gig or just go out i use the medium cut and it helps tremendously although the situations I am in are not considered loud its the musicians plugs or no go pretty much
i have a set of molded ones on order that from the audiologist where they made impression of my ear canal and the lab will insert a filter in one of two or three strengths
if 33 db cut isnt enough which is about the max available, it seems - i would look into musicians ear monitors (which i dont know much about) i have seen that they are the same custom molded ear canal internal ones and then they insert a mini ear phone transducer and plug into the board or the monitor so you can get fed the mix but can control that volume - the molded internal part protects you from natural surrounding noise you can add a pair of ear muffs over that that and probably get additional protection but still custom attenuate the mix an audiologist told me some of those custom molded ones can run up to $1k or more I think worth it
(either it looks silly or looks real cool -either way, who cares)
I just bought a very expensive set of 33db cut ear muffs for the firing range but it may not be enough I will have to add 33db foam inside the ears by the way the audiolist does gig out with a 60s-70s band after hours so he knows what the deal is - tells me to stop playing and shooting. the shooting will go first!
some of this is better than nothing
remember if the next day you feel it and have to recover a bit - that is permanent damage even though your ears seem to come back. It will catch up to you
like i said I have gigged with those medium cut inexpensive ones and it really makes the difference. the difference between playing and having to give it up again. i have no idea what i will be up against if i get into some louder music
i remember playing out in the sixties and my ears would almost recover by the time the next weekend rolled around and then it started all over again i am surprised i survived as well as i did but with great sacrifice
right now its touch and go
tinnitus has been my friend since the sixties its a buddy you are stuck with
sorry to ramble on like this but its something that has to be dealt with
will be glad to look up some info and suggest if anyone wants me to
no "macho ears" - get used to protecting them now
just my reaction and two cents
- Jerry
|
DrumsUp
Tiger Talk Pro
Reged: Dec 06 2005
Posts: 154
Loc: Cape Breton Nova Scotia Canada
|
|
Jerry, thanks for your post. I'm getting to where you are. I ask people to repeat themselves frequently, and my wife has (almost) learned to turn her head in my direction when we are having a conversation. I feel, sorry for our bass player who loves it loud, and refuses to use ear protection. Will he be able to hear his 3-year-old daughter's wedding vows when she's old enough to take them?
-------------------- "Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons, for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup."
|
bear45
Tiger Talk Pro
Reged: Dec 27 2003
Posts: 159
Loc: CT
|
|
Hard to say
I think i read somewhere that ENT guys and audiologists assessed baby boomers and our ilk (I was actually born 6 months before the official start of boomers but i consider myself a boomer - hah, yeah - BOOMER) Their estimate was that 50% exhibited significant hearing loss
I guess the first thing that goes is the high frequencies normal upper range is 15,000 hz or so
Being a drummer my audiograms showed a bite out of the consonant range which if I remember is about 1000 hz That was in my early 20s Last i saw an audiogram about 10 years ago i was shocked to see all the upper frequencies missing. i am on the edge now its touch and go I should be able to hold out for a few more years you start to loose the audio clues which the brain uses to perceive whats said. It can get like a Rorchach ink blot test and can be embarrassing as to what you personally think the key word is you are missing when it's clarified. LOL
All you can do is make your point to the bass player and let him take his lumps. He's been warned That's what I call "macho ears" My audiologist office called and my custom molded ear plugs are in and will make an appt. so they can show me how to insert them.
Problem i have with the ones i use now - they do attenuate linearly but in places i find I have to pull them out slightly so that i can catch a word or two because my highs are down so much it they are attenuated more than the rest. Sometimes so I cant make out the words Also with the ear plugs on I hear myself through the bone so I talk very low and others can't understand me.
Hey relating all this just to make a point. I am doing very well for my history and age I do what i can to keep it that way.
I thought it was interesting that some guy invented a drum throne that gets the signal from the monitor and puts all the vibration and impact into what the drummer is sitting on. I thought it was an interesting idea. In the day I preferred to be INSIDE the music. You FEEL the music pushing against you. It was a physical experience beyond just the audio.
Later this week if I get a chance i will post some URLS to products available just to get it on record.
You can lead a horse to water and only the strong survive - but strong doesn't mean that one personally can seem to handle more noise abuse i mean be strong and advocate and protect your hearing
Oh yeah, another thought - the classic reaction when someone has trouble making out speech in cluttered noisy environments is "you need to get hearing aids" Don't be so quick to do that. Do what you can before you get to that stage. (I think hearing aids is a racket like eyeglasses and their prices) all they do is boost the frequencies you don't hear well and you are just adding to the noise level punishment I watched my father deteriorate to nothing and those hearing aids really suck! They are rife with feedback and other problems. For anyone that is starting to have trouble in noisy environments try those inexpensive musicians ear plugs first. Most probably wont have the upper frequency loss i have and will actually be able to hear speech BETTER wit the attenuation! Don't fight against it get those NOW. Turn the volume DOWN before you have to turn the volume up because by that time its a progressively loosing battle. We go out to a place and i wear these things and at the end of the evening i take them out and its really comforting to see how much more serene and relaxed i am because my hearing has not been put on edge.
My opinion of this is to get used to wearing these things before its evident that damaging is occurring. There was an org. on the west coast that advocated these things - apparently they have disappeared and its a shame. These DJs and these characters with Marshall stacks should be legally regulated. (or shot) Sorry i have to say that
PEACE! (the serene kind, not the deafening silence and the hiss)
Again, sorry to relate all this but I feel strongly about it. I am doing very well with the modern plugs we have and hopefully will continue for a good time to come. If they only had these musicians ear plugs in my day!
Happy Music!
|
roger strange
Tiger Talk Pro
Reged: Dec 09 2003
Posts: 1650
Loc: Nova Scotia Canada
|
|
Well,I think we have been down this road before on these threads. Anyway. I started using Naval gunnery earplugs back in the 60s for the big Rock gigs. I still have them and also a second pair came my way about a decade ago. Don't know what they are called commercially. They have a ribbed ear insert outer shell of soft rubber which houses a piston-like sound sensitive cylinder. They work extremely well and I've seen them in older shooting range gear catalogues as well. And you guys are all very right. We DO need to carry some ear protection with us. One never knows when you come across some indulgent guitar player with twin Mesa Boogies or equivalent, who insists on putting the damned amps at the back of the stage one each side of the drummer. I started using the plugs when I was with an outfit called Grandstand in Toronto where the Hammond B-3 used twin Leslie 175s, the bass player used a Sunn 2000-s amp and the guitar player was using two honking Fender amps ganged in stereo up off the floor at shoulder level and the four horns and singer were coming at me through two monitors aimed right at me with 16" speakers and horns. Mind you I countered that honking sound with twin 26" Rogers bass drums on stun using the old Autocrat square mahogany wood mallets as well and some pretty heavy cymbals etc. All the amps and Leslies were sitting in a wall directly behind me and my riser. That set of Naval gunnery plugs saved my hearing 100% intact. And they are also small enough to fit in the ears under earphones so I have been known to use them in the studios from time to time. Especially when an engineer won't listen to me when I ask him/her to take down the volume in the cans. And I've dealt with plenty of those birds down this way in the studios since I came here from Toronto in 1972. I have found that at times it seems that the others in the bands actually go out of their way to hammer the drummer with high volume and dirty mixes.
Edited by roger strange (Fri Dec 16 2011 09:56 AM)
|